93 points - Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
"Rich and quite complex pinot noir with plum, wood smoke, liquorice, mixed spice and nutty oak flavours. Accessible now but with obvious cellaring potential, A robust and slightly rustic wine that's a pleasure to taste."
95 points - Bob Campbell, MW
"This youthful and complex pinot has abundant, sappy, spicy appeal with aromas of crushed violets, blueberries, blackberries, graphite, black tea and blue plums. The palate has a very succulent and vibrant feel with sturdy tannins, holding plenty of fresh blueberry and blue-plum flavor. So youthful and powerful, this is another great Pegasus Bay pinot. Try from 2023. Screw cap."
95 points - James Suckling