97 points - Wine Enthusiast
97 points - Vinous
94+ points - Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
18/20 points - Jancy Robinson
"Exceptional freshness with aromas of flinty white stones, flowers, almonds and lemons. There’s hazelnut and strawberry here, too. Complex. The palate has a long, powerful and smooth-honed feel with very assertive citrus flavors, driven by long acidity. A perfect 2008."
94+ points - Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
18/20 points - Jancy Robinson
"Exceptional freshness with aromas of flinty white stones, flowers, almonds and lemons. There’s hazelnut and strawberry here, too. Complex. The palate has a long, powerful and smooth-honed feel with very assertive citrus flavors, driven by long acidity. A perfect 2008."
100 points - James Suckling
"There’s a supernova of sensation with each sip of this powerful version, This burns bright from start to finish, yet its fine integration and lovely, raw silk–like mousse pull it all together into a seamless, vibrant package."
100 points - Wine Spectator