"This second edition made up of 75% of Chardonnays of different ages benefits from the richness of the 2012 vintage and the perfect balance of the 2014 vintage that occupy a large place in the heart of an intensified perpetual reserve. The remaining 25% of young Pinot Noirs from the terroir of Vertus energize the delicate mineral, saline and iodized expression of the Chardonnay and heighten the wine’s aromatic expression. Thanks to the Perrin family’s skills in Provence rosé, it reveals an incomparable hue of sublime brilliance that is the result of an elegant extraction of color by infusion. The density, balance, and persistence of ER2 are expressions of the magic of an outstanding rosé champagne from noble terroirs, born from unique winemaking choices expertly made by the Peters family. The wine is aged on lees in the dark in the Champagne house’s cellars for three years."
"Aromas of blood orange, cherries, toasted bread and grapefruit preface the NV Exclusivement Rosé 2, a medium to full-bodied, vinous and incisive wine that's rich and muscular, with incisive acids and a long, chalky finish. Based on the challenging 2017 vintage, it's a very fine success."
93 points - Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
"Pale pink red in colour. Very restrained autolysis aromas with firm, structural, mineral notes. On the palate, it has a tight mineral structure, dark, black cherry fruit and some almond notes. Initially tasting very young and unyielding, but with time in the glass opens up to reveal beautifully open fruit and charming richness. Dare I suggest it, maybe a Champagne not to be served straight from the ice bucket, but even consider decanting to get the full fruit. 2017 was a good vintage for the vintage Chardonnay component. Disgorged: April 2021. Dosage: 4g/L."
92 points - Decanter