93 points - Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
92 points - Wine Enthusiast
92 points - Wine Enthusiast
"This Californian version of the Great Australian Blend, combining Cabernet Sauvignon with Shiraz (grown from Penfolds’ South Australian vine cuttings) strikes immediate notes of familiarity. There's its spicy nose and easy harmony on the palate, seamlessly melding savoury comfort over a melange of rich red, blue and black fruit. Each component does its necessary work – the Cabernet bringing chew and texture and Shiraz giving a comforting cuddle until the blackberry grunt returns to deliver a stern final bass note."
95 points - Decanter
"A Californian cabernet sauvignon and shiraz (83/17%) blend sourced from vineyards in the Napa Valley, Sonoma and Paso Robles. Matured for 17 months in American oak (40% new). This brings back memories of the time I spent researching and writing my Wine Atlas of California. It's a pity Penfolds hasn't given a regional percentage breakdown, but there's a succulent, juicy mouthfeel and flavour, and a fanfare of blue and black berries. *Silver*"
94 points - James Halliday