91 points. - Vinous

“Better than its predecessors, this third release of Penfolds working with Bordeaux fruit adds 14% Petit Verdot and 8% Merlot to Cabernet Sauvignon from a variety of Bordeaux vineyards. Its rich purple colour is matched by a whiff of pretty purple blooms and freshly picked sage and marjoram. Subdued flavours are very dry on entry, carrying an almost sooty edge, before a gorgeous silky mid-palate texture allows plum and wild strawberry notes to glide to a firm finish with grip in the tail. It has admirable restraint and poise, and will reward tasters after at least seven years of cellaring.Drink 2024 - 2040.” 

94 points. – Decanter

“78/14/8% cabernet sauvignon/petit verdot/merlot. The third release of the Penfolds French Winemaking Trial from vineyards across Bordeaux. Solid crimson with aromas of macerated summer berry fruits, baking spices, purple flowers, cedar, berry cream and plum conserve. From the bouquet you'd expect a fruit-forward palate expression but it's gravelly with ferrous tannins marching strong. Structurally, it's lovely ... a melding of antipodean winemaking nous and classic French terroir."

94 points.  – James Halliday's Wine Companion