91 points - Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
"A like the smoky and grilled-meat character to the fruit here. Full-bodied, layered and ripe with freshness and intensity. Bright and focused. Remains bright and energetic. Drink now. Screw cap."
93 points - James Suckling
"86/14% Margaret River/Geographe. 89/7/2/1% shiraz/alicante boushet/viognier/grenache. On skins for up to 48 days, 18 months on lees in French oak (35% new). The complex regional/varietal blending has blurred the clarity of the shiraz. This clearly has class and presence, but it lacks precise expression of region and variety."
91 points - James Halliday